Yentl’s 25th

From March ’09 Spotlight: Barbra Streisand’s Yentl has just been rereleased in a brand new 25th anniversary DVD box set. Although much maligned over the years, Yentl is a great and heartfelt work of cinematic art, and I urge you all to watch it again with fresh eyes in celebration of Women’s History Month.

The narrative is based on a novella by Isaac Bashevis Singer, but while Singer tells his tale from the outside (as a man reflecting on a troubled sister whose emotional life was always a mystery to him), Barbra Streisand uses her renown voice as a vehicle for self-exploration, taking us deep into the heart and soul of a Jewish woman on the edge of modernity.

In November 2007, I had the honor of interviewing Alan and Marilyn Bergman when they came to town as guests of the Chicago Humanities Festival. The Bergmans won an Oscar for their Yentl lyrics in 1984 (which they shared with composer Michel Legrand), and we spent our entire hour together talking about Yentl.

“Alan and I had read the story when it first came out,” Marilyn told me. “And we had remarked to each other that it would be wonderful material to musicalize because of the inner life of this character Yentl.”

“Barbra Streisand called us one night. She said, ‘I’m never going to get the screenplay I want. I’m tired of trying.’ At the end of that conversation, we said to her, ‘Have you ever thought of it as a musical?’ She said, ‘No, of course not.’ So that was the end of the conversation. Five minutes later she called back and said, ‘How would you do this as a musical?’ So we told her that we had long felt that it was kind of an inner monologue. Then she went to the studio, the studio that had been rejecting the idea of Yentl as a film, and when they heard she was going to sing, it was a whole different story.”

Alan told me, “She understood it exactly…” and Marilyn finished his sentence, “Oh instantly, of course she did. Yentl has nobody else to tell of this whole life that she’s living once she puts on a man’s clothing. She is disguising the most essential part of herself, her sexuality! So anyway, then the studio gave it the green light.”

And the rest, as they say, is history. For more from my interview with Alan and Marilyn Bergman, visit


Alan & Marilyn Bergman at the Chicago Humanities Festival (with Andrew Ezrin on left).

Photo Credit: Jan Lisa Huttner (10/27/07)

Tags: Alan & Marilyn Bergman, Alan and Marilyn Bergman, Alan Bergman, Barbra Streisand, Isaac Bashevis Singer, Marilyn Bergman, Yentl
Previous Post Next Post


  1. Pingback: The Muses of IBS | Second City Tzivi

Leave a Reply